Frank couldn’t really prevent destiny. She just accepted it, mainly because she'd fallen for the Scot, and in her eyes, Frank wasn't now the person she loved. A subreddit for the Diana Gabaldon book series and STARZ television show. " Frank ( Tobias Menzies) died in Sunday's episode of Outlander 's third season, " All Debts Paid," after 18 years spent in a romantic-loveless marriage with Claire (. Related: Outlander: 5 Relationships Fans Were Behind (And 5 They Rejected) One thing that Outlander manages to do rather well is create amazing characters. But that doesn't mean the man doesn't deserve our pity. Maybe they wouldn't fall back in love but they'd understand each other better and be happier, maybe even bond over her stories. Frank is simply a man of the 1940s. IMDb, the world's most popular and authoritative source for movie, TV and celebrity content. Duncan Lacroix is not those things. Claire Never Takes Off Her Ring From Frank. In fact, the Final Argument started with Frank and Claire spooning together in bed. Then there is the story. And nothing you could ever do would stop my loving me,” he replied. And Frank spent his every moment reaching out to Claire and attempting to make her happy despite knowing that she couldn’t give it back to him in return. . The series led fans to believe that BJR was Frank Randall's direct ancestor, even more so because he was played by actor Tobias Menzies, who also played Frank. " Claire is a person with choices and she agreed to go back to Frank with the conditions. Kilda’s but as Roger concluded, it led to the events that took Claire, Bree and Roger to the past, to Jamie. Frank's insistence that she never speak of her travels always confused me, especially because he's a historian and she personally knew his ancestor who he was studying so much. Actually, in Voyager Frank and Claire slept together up to the day Frank died. All throughout Claire’s marriage to Jamie, she wears his ring that he had made for her out of the key from Lallybroch. He didn't do anything to deserve how he's being treated. Tobias Menzies, Outlander. Frank Randall, Outlander. I think there's no doubt, watching Claire and Frank together in Episode 101 ("Sassenach") and in the brief flashbacks in later episodes, that they loved each other very much. In fact, in one important scene, Frank tells Claire that he’d still love her no matter what she does. Every woman wants to hear words like that! Frank was a good father, even if he wasn’t always a good husband, and he didn’t deserve to die before he had a chance to truly be happy. At first, he believed Claire to be either a liar or crazy. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. When she’s with Frank in Boston she thinks Jamie is dead and so she’s mourning the loss of one husband, rather missing a husband she can return to. He's 6'2", and has a well-kept beard and head of hair on the show. Three, love. I honestly am losing alot of sympathy for Claire watching their relationship when she gets back. In the book, Jamie gifts his wife. 16 votes, 44 comments. The biggest difference between Show Frank and Book Frank is when they were written. Jamie gives her a pearl necklace. Communication is always better than silence. In the show, it was Claire who initiated sex with Frank. I love you. Claire knew this - she was also from that time, and she knew how attitudes were at the time. Frank stopped having sex with Claire, claiming that her eyes being closed during sex meant she was thinking of Jamie. At some point, he learned that Claire had told him the truth. “In defense of #Outlander's Frank Randall, he deserved better One of the worst things Claire did to Frank (and the most obvious entry on the list) had to be when Claire chose Jamie. The show writers aren’t afraid to put in tons of twists and turns to keep viewers glued to their TV screens, even if it means sacrificing a character we’ve come to love. But even though they are married, in love, and have created a life together, she still wears the gold band Frank gave her when they were married. I absolutely love Jamie and Claire and nothing compares to their love. r/Outlander • Frank Deserved Better. And Episode 108 ("Both Sides Now") makes it abundantly clear that Frank. One, awkward first time sex. It’s not an apples with apples comparison otherwise. While Claire was happily starting her new life. - (not saying she would have completely opened her heart to Frank again ) Edit: Tobias Menzies is the reason why there is sympathy for Frank. Frank wasn’t a perfect man but he seemed pretty damn close. Frank deserved better. I'm watching for the first time and I feel so badly for Frank. We’ll never know whether Claire could ever love Frank again because he never tried. There are three types of sex shown here. I quite liked the… Gifted, a return to modest-budget Hallmark-shop sentimentality for the filmmaker, is a custody battle melodrama that’s as schmaltzy as all get out. Yes I feel bad for her, but she was better off on her own. However it’s so unfortunate that… Yes Frank did even worse with the placing of the stone at St. I know its an obviously crazy situation but she is wholly just using him. Chris Evans stars as Frank, a soft-spoken. But now it is widely known and is almost part of pop culture. No Spin-Off: Frank Randall. The Outlander music is just incredible. Any comparison of the two relationships needs to from pre-time jump in season one, not from when Claire returns. The episodes leading up to the. His appearance isn't the only thing that changed from the Outlander books to the television. It makes me sad how little he got. Hopefully987 • 2 yr. and then having his marriage break down, and. The relationship between Claire & Frank could have been better if Frank allowed for Claire to process her grief instead of shutting it all inside and not allowed to talk about any of it. She even actualizes this fear by withholding Frank’s meds and later shooting him. RELATED: Outlander: 10 Facts About Frank And Brianna From The Books The Show Leaves Out. Keep in mind the first book was an experiment for the author. of. Here are 13 TV characters who deserved better. Crypto Frank took her back, at least in part, and I would say in large part, because he didn’t look like a cad. This was the main reason he agreed to take back Claire and the baby. "Frank didn't know he was infertile until Bree was a teenager. I get in the early days when people did not know about it. In the books, Frank only appears alive in the first three. He never told her. None of them are perfect, but they all come together to deliver some of the best stories we've ever seen played out on-screen. 72K subscribers in the Outlander community. Dead or alive? Who knew! For years! And when she did return, she was pregnant with another man's child. He checked it while Claire was away, as he discussed it with the Reverend in Through A Glass Darkly. Aimee Spinks, For all of Frank Randall's ( Tobias Menzies) faults on Outlander, he tried. 516 votes, 30 comments. r/orangeisthenewblack • If Big Boo didn't exist, it would have been necessary to invent her. The “wee cheetie,” as Jamie calls him, makes his first appearance in The Fiery Cross, the Diana Gabaldon novel on which Season 5 of the Starz drama is based. Although Frank is a major character, and yet, one that doesn't get a whole lot of screen time, he's just not the best candidate for a spin-off. I have now read multiple books where the characters in the book are watching Outlander and comment about it. I never was a massive fan of Frank. Frank loved Claire but not enough to sacrifice or to take a chance. I know that we compare Frank’s behavior with Jamie taking Claire back to the stones so that she could go back to Frank if she so. When Show Frank was written, seven of the current 8 books had been written. Frank first met Claire when he came to consult her uncle, Quentin Beauchamp, an archaeologist and. At some point Frank knew Claire had told the absolute truth about what happened to her, yet he left her thinking he still thought she was a liar or crazy. I wonder if they're going to villianize him later to. Frank Randall was an English-born historian in the 20th century. However, no one asked her to do these things, and she was warned multiple times about Frank’s exploitive behavior. ago. the way i hate sloan for breaking marks heart the way she did. Showtime’s Shameless finally reached its conclusion after eleven seasons. The Gallaghers deserved a better ending on Shameless. Two, passionate, “omg I get to have sex with my spouse all the time” sex . I wouldn’t say I dislike him, but I just feel we didn’t see enough of him for me to really… In many ways, Frank in the TV series is a more sympathetic character than he appears in the books. If one thing is for sure, it’s that Outlander definitely doesn’t spare the drama. BJR Wasn't Frank's Direct Ancestor. Frank Randall is no Jamie Fraser — Claire, an Outlander fan, a random person on the street, we as a society can all, collectively, agree on this. Sammi’s behavior definitely suggests an intense fear of abandonment. Frank Randall In episode 3 of Outlander, "All Debts Paid," Jamie's old foe John Grey returns, Frank finally asks for a divorce, and Claire becomes a doctor. He spent his whole life loving Claire and though she loved him, it couldn’t hold a candle to her great love for Jamie. Outlander season six is on its way but fans have been sharing their unpopular opinions on the show (Starz) Kicking things off themselves, u/awkwardOttakam added: "Jaime and Claire are symbols of true love and what not but they are sickly unlucky for each other and just take turns to cause trouble for the other (unintentionally of course, but. Following years of trials and tribulations for the Gallaghers, “Father Frank, Full of Grace” delivers a series finale that fails to reach the emotional climax of a true ending. “All I meant was is that even if you, it would make no difference to me. Hannah Deserved Better 😭. His story (in essence) involves him losing his wife, searching for his wife, giving his wife up for dead, finding his wife. . Here are the ten best characters on Outlander. He was married to Claire Beauchamp Randall, and had one daughter, though not biological, Brianna Randall. Incredible acting by most. She did nothing to try persuade Frank to think differently. However, in season 2, it was revealed that it wasn't BJR, but his brother Alex and his lover Mary Hawkins, who were Frank's direct ancestors. The scenery is unbelievable. i kinda feel like she was punishing him for not being there and kept coming back for… Frank and Brianna deserved better :( [#outlander #scottland #tvshow #acting #starz #outlanderstarz #fy #clanlands #briannafraser #frankrandall #sophieskelton #tobiasmenzies @hobbit_lord. He raised a baby that clearly wasn’t his, tried to win an uphill battle for his marriage… Business, Economics, and Finance. rings] original sound - Outlander <3 Frank deserved love. He deserved better. . 1. In "The Devil's Mark," the love triangle between Frank-Claire-Jamie came to a close when the future surgeon chose to stay in the eighteenth-century instead of returning to Frank. Ad Meanwhile, in 18th century Scotland… I've been watching Outlander with the family (note: we're all adults) during quarantine, and honestly, I don't like it much at all. Frank got his way for 18 years. First of all, the man's wife disappeared. He traced his lineage back to Jonathan Randall, an English officer involved with the Jacobite Rising of 1745, and Mary Hawkins. 37 votes, 32 comments. " Not in the show. Hear me out: Claire yelling at Frank for having an affair is literally such a joke after all that poor guy has been through… 22 votes, 19 comments.